Picture a candidate applying for a seasonal role at their local store. They are on their phone, probably on a break from another job, with a few minutes to spare. If the application asks them to create an account, upload a CV they do not have and then complete a lengthy form designed for an office job, there is a good chance they will close the page and apply elsewhere. The candidates most likely to leave are often the strongest, because they have other options.
For years, retailers have been expected to hire frontline teams with the same recruitment technology used for corporate roles. High-volume hiring works differently. Candidates apply from their phones, hiring managers work on the shop floor and roles need filling in days. When the tools do not reflect that, retailers lose good candidates before meeting them and end up choosing from whoever is left.
Retail leaders know this matters. In the 2026 Talent Transformation Yearbook, from Kyle & Co and ICIMS, which surveyed 500 HR and talent leaders, 28% named high-volume and frontline hiring capacity as their top priority for 2027. Yet 46% described their current approach as mostly reactive. This peak season is a chance to close that gap.
A smaller candidate pool raises the stakes
Retailers are heading into peak season with a smaller candidate pool. According to the ICIMS Insights October Workforce Report, high-volume application volume ended September 18% below the September 2025 baseline, while high-volume hiring cooled to 8% below baseline. In the US, Challenger, Gray & Christmas reports retailers are planning their smallest seasonal hiring push since 2008, relying more on existing staff and automation.
The pool is also getting younger. ICIMS data shows Gen Z makes up 40% of the holiday applicant pool. This generation expects to apply from a phone, hear back quickly and know exactly what a role offers before committing.
With fewer applicants, every abandoned application or slow response costs more. Losing even a handful of strong candidates leaves fewer good options and makes quality harder to protect.
Smart retailers are also looking at who they already know. During seasonal hiring, Urban Outfitters Inc., which covers a portfolio of brands, including Urban Outfitters, Anthropologie, Free People, Nuuly and more, used ICIMS CRM to re-engage former employees and past applicants to other brands and locations, giving hiring managers a ready-made pool of known talent instead of starting every search from scratch. Finding people is only half the job, though. The other half is making it easy for them to apply and keeping them engaged through to offer.
Volume and quality go hand in hand
High-volume hiring is often treated as a numbers game, where the goal is simply to fill shifts. In a tight market, though, volume and quality depend on each other. Quality depends on volume, because managers can only choose the strongest candidate if enough good applicants make it through the process. Volume depends on quality, because a poor seasonal hire affects customer experience, piles pressure on colleagues and often leaves before the busiest weeks are over, which sends the store straight back to hiring.
Retail leaders recognise this. Research by ICIMS and Lighthouse Research & Advisory among 460+ high-volume and frontline employers found that 61% say quality of hire is their leadership’s most important hiring metric, and 62% say selecting the most capable candidate is their top recruitment priority. But that standard is hard to hold when demand is unpredictable. Forty-two percent of those employers said their high-volume hiring needs exceeded their forecasts. When a store suddenly needs more people, the pressure is to fill shifts fast, and quality is the first thing put at risk.
The answer is not choosing between speed and standards. Retailers need a candidate experience that brings in enough strong applicants, keeps them engaged and helps managers spot the right fit quickly, so they can scale up without lowering the bar. That is why the frontline candidate experience deserves its own design.

Built for how frontline candidates apply and store managers hire
It starts with the device in the candidate’s pocket. ICIMS High Volume Hiring uses mobile-first, AI-powered conversations over SMS, WhatsApp and the web, so candidates can find roles, answer a few relevant questions and apply in minutes, whenever it suits them. AI job matching points them towards roles that fit their skills and availability. Being upfront about pay, shifts and hours in the conversation helps the right people commit early and reduces early turnover.
The other half belongs to the store manager. A dedicated mobile workspace brings candidate information, screening, interview scheduling and approvals together, so a manager can act in a few minutes between customers. Strong candidates get an interview while they are still interested. Real-time dashboards show application volume, conversion rates and time in stage, so bottlenecks surface before they hit staffing levels. And because it is built on the ICIMS Intelligent Hiring Platform, retailers keep the workflows, compliance and analytics a large organisation needs.
Where AI earns its place in high-volume hiring
The ICIMS and Lighthouse research found that 75% of high-volume employers say AI has reduced their recruiting team’s workload, and 48% are increasing their AI investment. In retail, AI is most useful for the repetitive, round-the-clock work, such as answering a candidate’s question at ten at night, screening for availability and eligibility and booking interviews around a manager’s schedule. Organisations using ICIMS High Volume Hiring have reported up to 75% faster time to fill, 90% less recruiter admin and capacity to manage up to 10 times more hires.
The time AI saves goes back into better decisions. AI surfaces the candidates who meet a role’s needs and store managers make the final call on who joins their team.
The gains come from being deliberate about where AI sits in the process. In the Yearbook, organisations that rated themselves above average on all six hiring outcomes, including time to hire, quality of hire and new hire retention, run an average of six AI hiring capabilities in production, versus two and a half among the lowest performers. For retailers protecting quality of hire with fewer applicants, the takeaway is to put AI where hiring actually stalls and build out from there. When AI supports your hiring process, in the right places, the stronger the hires tend to be.
Planning for 2027 now
Moving from reactive to planned can start this season. A hiring experience built for the frontline gives retailers real-time visibility into application volume, conversion rates and time in stage, so they can see where candidates drop out, how long managers take to respond and which steps slow down when demand spikes. Fixing those points now means going into the next peak with a process that has already been tested, instead of running into the same problems again.
The real test of this season’s hiring comes in the new year, when retailers see how many of their seasonal hires are still on the schedule and ready for the next peak. That is the clearest measure of quality of hire, and the one that will matter most heading into 2027.